Mays Classic Donut Shop – New Castle, PA: Hours & Menu

Opening hours

Eastern Time

Opening hours have not been published for this bakery yet. Call (724) 654-4141 to check today's hours. Know the hours? Send them to us.

Tap for directions

Rigotti's Plaza, 1214 Butler Ave, New Castle, PA 16101

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps

AddressRigotti's Plaza, 1214 Butler Ave, New Castle, PA 16101

Phone(724) 654-4141

StyleDonut shop

CountyLawrence County

Time zoneEastern Time

From city center1.6 mi east

About Mays Classic Donut Shop

Mays Classic Donut Shop is a donut shop at Rigotti's Plaza, 1214 Butler Ave, about 1.6 mi east of central New Castle.

Our New Castle directory counts 8 bakeries in total, roughly one for every 2,667 residents. The closest neighbour on our map is La Mangia, 1.6 mi away.

We have not been able to confirm a full weekly schedule for Mays Classic Donut Shop yet, so calling ahead at (724) 654-4141 is the safest bet. Bakeries often sell out of popular items by early afternoon.

What to order

Typical items at a donut shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Yeast-raised

Glazed twistTwo strands of yeast dough twisted together, fried and glazed, giving more chewy edges and glaze-catching crevices than a standard ring.
Cinnamon sugar raisedWarm, fluffy yeast donut tossed in cinnamon sugar instead of glaze, with a grainy, sparkling coating over the soft interior.
Chocolate long johnOblong raised donut topped with chocolate icing; a Midwest counter favorite with a bready bite and plenty of frosting per mouthful.
Glazed ringLight, airy yeast donut fried golden and dipped in a thin vanilla glaze that sets into a sheer, crackly sugar shell.

Cake donuts

Buttermilk barRectangular buttermilk cake donut with a crisp, glazed shell and a tangy, close-grained center that pairs well with drip coffee.
Old-fashionedSour cream cake donut with cracked, craggy edges that fry extra crisp, finished with a glaze that pools in every fissure.
Blueberry cakePurple-flecked cake donut flavored with blueberry and glazed all over; moist, close crumb with a fruity, slightly jammy taste.
Chocolate cake donutDeep cocoa cake donut, plain or glazed, with a fine, tight crumb and a flavor somewhere between brownie and devil's food cake.

Filled donuts

Boston creamRound yeast shell piped full of vanilla custard and topped with glossy chocolate frosting, echoing the classic Boston cream pie.
Jelly-filledSugar-dusted pillow of fried dough filled with raspberry or strawberry jelly that tends to escape with the first bite.
Bavarian creamYeast donut filled with a thick, pudding-like Bavarian cream and dusted with powdered sugar; rich, cool and lightly vanilla.
Lemon-filledGranulated-sugar-coated shell holding bright, tangy lemon curd; a sharp citrus counterpoint to the sweet fried dough.